The Agent Roth Brief · Issue 01017 min read

Roth Conversions Before RMDs: How They Can Change Your First Required Distribution

The direct answer

The direct answer

A Roth conversion completed before RMDs begin removes the converted amount from the pre-tax account used to calculate future required distributions. If that movement produces a smaller prior December 31 pre-tax balance, the future RMD may also be smaller after division by the applicable IRS life-expectancy factor. Returns, withdrawals, contributions, and transaction timing can change both balances. The conversion itself does not satisfy a future RMD. [1] [2] [4]

The tradeoff occurs earlier: previously untaxed conversion dollars generally enter gross income in the conversion year. A lower projected RMD therefore does not automatically mean lower lifetime taxes or a better financial result. The current tax, payment source, Medicare, Social Security, cash-flow, and survivor effects are separate parts of the comparison. [4] [5]

Official support:[1][2][4][5]

A fixed, calculator-generated comparison shows how nine annual pre-RMD conversions may change a first projected RMD and later pre-tax and Roth balances.

Written by Agent Roth Editorial Team

Published Updated Sources verified 17 min read

Publication does not imply tax-professional review. Read the editorial policy and corrections policy.

RMDs and Roth ConversionsRoth Conversion TaxesPlanning Examples

Introduction

The years after employment income declines but before required minimum distributions begin can be a potential planning window. Social Security may not have started, Medicare may or may not have begun, mandatory taxable distributions are not yet present, and pre-tax retirement balances may still be compounding.

That period is not universally low-tax. Pension income, investment gains, a working spouse, Medicare’s income lookback, state tax, or a large conversion can make a year expensive. Some households may have no favorable window at all. The useful question is whether a defined conversion schedule is worth modeling alongside a no-conversion path.

How is an RMD calculated?

General RMD formula

Projected RMD = prior December 31 applicable account balance

÷ applicable IRS life-expectancy factor

This is a planning illustration. An official RMD uses the actual applicable balance, table, beneficiary facts, plan terms, and law for that distribution year.

The prior year-end balance supplies the numerator. An original owner normally uses the Uniform Lifetime Table. The Joint and Last Survivor Table may apply when the spouse is the sole beneficiary for the entire year and is more than ten years younger. The Single Life Table generally serves different beneficiary situations outside this article. [1] [2]

Each IRA generally receives its own calculation, although eligible Traditional, SEP, and SIMPLE IRA RMD amounts may generally be aggregated and withdrawn from one or more of those IRAs. Employer-plan RMDs can have separate withdrawal and aggregation rules. Inherited accounts are outside this worked example. [2] [6]

When do RMDs begin?

There is no single starting age for everyone. Under the final regulations, owners born before July 1, 1949 may fall under the age-70½ framework; later 1949 and 1950 births generally use age 72; 1951 through 1958 births generally use age 73; and people born in 1960 or later generally use age 75. [3]

Traditional, SEP, and SIMPLE IRA owners do not receive a still-working delay merely because they remain employed. A current employer plan may allow a later start until retirement, depending on plan terms, but the exception generally does not apply to a more-than-5% owner. Account type, employer, ownership, and birth year therefore belong in the same review. [2] [6]

How can a conversion before RMDs affect the calculation?

Simplified account flow—not a tax calculation
Pre-tax retirement account
Taxable Roth conversion
Roth account: future modeled growth occurs on the Roth side

The converted amount leaves the modeled pre-tax balance and enters the modeled Roth balance. If the pre-tax account reaches a future December 31 with less money than an otherwise identical no-conversion path, the next RMD may be lower because the same applicable factor is dividing a smaller balance.

The conversion generally creates current taxable income. Withholding from the retirement distribution reduces the amount reaching Roth; paying tax from outside funds preserves more of the conversion in Roth but gives up other uses and potential growth for that cash. Market performance can amplify or overwhelm the modeled difference. The transaction changes where assets sit—it does not “save” an RMD or prove tax savings. [5]

Worked example — no conversions versus annual conversions

This fixed illustration calls the same tested production engine used by the Future RMD & Roth Conversion Impact Calculator. Both paths start in 2026 for an owner born in 1960, age 66, with $1,000,000 pre-tax and $100,000 Roth. Both assume a constant 5% annual return, no contributions, the Uniform Lifetime Table, a first RMD at age 75 in 2035, and an ending age of 95.

The conversion path moves $50,000 annually at ages 66 through 74, for nine modeled conversions totaling $450,000. The annual convention matches the calculator: identify beginning balances and age; calculate an RMD from the beginning balance when due; apply growth; add contributions; subtract the RMD; then subtract a capped conversion from pre-tax and add it to Roth. The first RMD is taken in its distribution year rather than delayed.

Shared-engine projection in nominal dollars; displayed values are rounded to the nearest dollar
ResultNo modeled conversionsAnnual modeled conversionsDifference
Pre-tax balance immediately before first RMD calculation$1,551,328$1,000,000−$551,328
First projected RMD$63,062$40,650−$22,412
Roth balance at first RMD age$155,133$706,461+$551,328
Total amount converted$0$450,000+$450,000
Cumulative projected RMDs through age 85$875,731$564,504−$311,227
Pre-tax balance at age 85$1,546,295$996,756−$549,540
Roth balance at age 85$265,330$1,208,288+$942,958

Recreate this example in the Future RMD & Roth Conversion Impact Calculator. Load the example or enter the assumptions to examine every annual row. The calculator requires no contact information and keeps entries in the browser.

What the example does and does not show

Scope of the worked example
IncludedNot included
A modeled shift from pre-tax to RothFederal or state conversion tax
Constant 5% annual growthInvestment volatility or fees
Lower projected pre-tax balancesTax paid from outside assets or lost growth on that cash
Lower projected first and later RMDsMedicare IRMAA or Social Security taxation
Higher projected Roth balancesSurvivor filing status, deductions, credits, or estate outcomes
One transparent annual timing conventionFuture law changes, custodian procedures, or plan restrictions

Why conversion taxes must be part of the comparison

Previously untaxed conversion amounts generally enter gross income. Additional income may occupy higher ordinary-income brackets, affect deductions or credits, and create a need for additional withholding or estimated payments. Withholding from the converted account means less reaches Roth; using outside cash carries its own opportunity cost. [4] [5]

This Brief deliberately does not calculate exact tax. Review How Roth Conversions Are Taxed, the 2026 conversion-tax payment deadlines, and the Roth Conversion Tax-Bracket & IRMAA Calculator as separate parts of the analysis.

Can a pre-RMD conversion affect Medicare or Social Security?

Medicare IRMAA

Taxable conversion income generally affects adjusted gross income. Medicare IRMAA generally uses tax information from two years earlier and adds tax-exempt interest to AGI for its MAGI measure. A conversion before RMDs can therefore increase a later Medicare premium even though no RMD was due in the conversion year. Read the current Agent Roth 2026 IRMAA guide rather than judging timing from RMDs alone.

Social Security taxation

Conversion income can increase the combined-income calculation used to determine how much Social Security is included in taxable income. Starting benefits and converting in the same year can change the comparison; this does not mean Social Security is taxed at a special conversion rate. The dedicated Social Security taxation guide explains the interaction.

Related reading: 2026 Roth conversion and IRMAA guide and Roth conversions and Social Security taxation.

What happens after RMDs have already begun?

Roth conversions may generally still be possible after RMDs begin. The required amount itself is not an eligible rollover distribution and cannot become the conversion. The applicable RMD must still be satisfied; an additional eligible amount may generally be converted afterward. Both amounts may increase income in the same year, and procedures should be confirmed with the custodian. [1] [4]

The separate Brief Does a Roth Conversion Count as an RMD? owns the detailed same-year sequence. Reaching RMD age does not by itself end every conversion opportunity.

Could a conversion reduce every future RMD?

A smaller modeled pre-tax balance may lead to smaller future RMDs than an otherwise identical no-conversion scenario. The difference changes every year as returns, withdrawals, contributions, conversion amounts, life-expectancy factors, and account depletion compound. Law changes can alter the rules entirely.

The fixed example shows smaller RMDs through age 85 under its assumptions. A real account will not earn exactly 5% every year, and future cash flows may differ between scenarios. It would be inaccurate to guarantee that every future RMD will be lower under every real-world outcome.

Does the first-RMD delay change the analysis?

Two ways the first distribution year can appear
  1. First RMD year

    Take the first RMD by December 31

    The calculator and worked example use this convention so each projected distribution stays in its applicable year.

  2. Following year

    Potential April 1 first-RMD deadline

    Current rules may permit the first RMD to be delayed until April 1 of the following year, depending on the applicable beginning date.

  3. Same following year

    The second RMD may still be due by December 31

    A delay can place two RMDs in one calendar year; adding a conversion could make that an especially large income year.

The first-year delay does not erase the first distribution. This example assumes it is taken in the first RMD year, simplifying the comparison without recommending either timing choice. [1] [2]

Which accounts should be included?

Original-owner lifetime RMD treatment at the August 2, 2026 source review
Account typeGeneral treatment
Traditional, SEP, and SIMPLE IRAGenerally subject to lifetime RMD rules; no still-working exception for the IRA owner.
Traditional employer planGenerally subject to RMD rules; a still-working delay may depend on employment, plan terms, and ownership.
Roth IRANo lifetime RMD for the original owner.
Designated Roth 401(k) or 403(b)No lifetime RMD for the original owner under current rules.
Inherited accountSeparate beneficiary rules; outside this example.

Do not combine accounts with different RMD start assumptions into one simplified balance without disclosure. An IRA and a current employer plan may not share the same beginning date or aggregation rules. [2] [3] [6]

Questions to review before using a pre-RMD conversion projection

  1. What is the verified RMD start age for my birth year?
  2. Which accounts are subject to RMDs?
  3. Does a still-working employer-plan exception apply?
  4. What are the current account balances?
  5. What growth assumptions are being used?
  6. How much is proposed for conversion each year?
  7. What portion is expected to be taxable?
  8. Is IRA basis present?
  9. How will conversion taxes be paid?
  10. Could Medicare IRMAA be affected?
  11. Could Social Security taxation be affected?
  12. Are RMDs expected to be needed for spending?
  13. Are charitable distributions part of the plan?
  14. What happens under lower and higher investment returns?
  15. What happens after one spouse dies?
  16. Are current tax brackets being compared with potential future brackets?
  17. Has the projection been updated for current law?

Frequently asked questions

Can Roth conversions reduce future RMDs?

They may reduce projected RMDs when the conversion leaves a smaller pre-tax prior year-end balance than an otherwise identical path. The conversion tax and complete household outcome still need separate analysis.

How do Roth conversions affect the first RMD?

A pre-RMD conversion moves assets out of the account used for the future calculation. If the prior December 31 balance is smaller, dividing by the applicable factor may produce a smaller first RMD.

Are RMDs based on the current balance or prior year-end balance?

An RMD is generally based on the applicable retirement-account balance as of the prior December 31 divided by the applicable life-expectancy factor.

When do RMDs begin?

The applicable beginning age depends on birth date and may also depend on account type, employment, plan terms, and ownership. Earlier cohorts can use 70½ or 72, later cohorts generally use 73 or 75.

Is RMD age 73 or 75?

It depends on birth year. Under current final regulations, many people born from 1951 through 1958 use 73, while people born in 1960 or later generally use 75.

What is the rule for someone born in 1959?

The cited 2024 final regulations reserve the specific 1959 paragraph because statutory language overlaps. Verify current guidance for that birth year rather than treating a calculator default as definitive.

Can I convert before RMDs begin?

Eligible retirement assets may generally be converted before RMDs begin. Eligibility, taxable amount, plan access, and the broader income effects still matter.

Can I convert after RMDs begin?

Often, yes. The required amount must remain separate, but an additional eligible amount may generally be converted after the RMD is satisfied.

Does a conversion count as an RMD?

No. A Roth conversion does not satisfy the required distribution for the year.

Can the RMD itself be converted?

No. The required amount is not an eligible rollover distribution and cannot itself be moved to Roth as a conversion.

Do Roth IRAs have lifetime RMDs?

Original Roth IRA owners generally do not have lifetime RMDs. Beneficiary distribution rules are separate.

Do Roth 401(k)s have lifetime RMDs?

Original owners of designated Roth accounts generally do not have lifetime RMDs under current rules. Beneficiary rules remain separate.

Does lowering an RMD guarantee lower taxes?

No. A conversion generally accelerates taxable income, and lower later distributions do not prove lower lifetime taxes or a better after-tax result.

How much should be converted before RMDs?

There is no universal amount. A useful model compares several amounts while accounting for taxes, cash, basis, Medicare, Social Security, spending, and future uncertainty.

Can a conversion increase Medicare premiums?

It can. Taxable conversion income may increase the MAGI used for a later IRMAA determination, generally using tax data from two years earlier.

Can conversion income affect Social Security taxation?

It can increase the combined-income calculation and may cause more benefits to be included in taxable income, depending on the complete return.

Does the calculator include conversion taxes?

No. The RMD impact calculator compares balances and distributions only; federal and state conversion taxes, withholding, and payment-source opportunity costs are excluded.

Which IRS table determines the RMD?

An original owner normally uses the Uniform Lifetime Table. The Joint and Last Survivor Table may apply when the spouse is sole beneficiary and more than ten years younger.

Can the first RMD be delayed?

The first RMD may generally be delayed until April 1 of the following year, subject to the applicable beginning-date rules. Later annual RMDs generally remain due by December 31.

Does delaying the first RMD create two RMDs in one year?

It can. Delaying the first distribution into the following year can place it in the same calendar year as the second RMD.

Key takeaways

  • Future RMDs generally depend on prior year-end pre-tax balances.
  • A pre-RMD Roth conversion moves assets out of the modeled pre-tax balance.
  • A smaller future pre-tax balance may produce a smaller future RMD.
  • The conversion generally creates taxable income earlier.
  • Lower RMDs do not automatically mean lower lifetime taxes.
  • Birth year, account type, tax effects, Medicare, Social Security, and cash flow all matter.

Primary sources

Rules and thresholds may change. These official federal sources support the concepts discussed above; their inclusion does not imply government endorsement of Agent Roth.

This material is general education and is not individualized tax, legal, investment, rollover, or financial advice. The example is illustrative, uses constant assumptions, excludes taxes and withholding, and does not recommend a Roth conversion, amount, schedule, or RMD timing choice. Verify current law, account values, plan terms, and tax effects with appropriately qualified professionals before acting. Read the educational and financial disclosures.